Israel

Ignoring the oppression of Palestinians by the Lebanese army

Recently on Twitter I have witnessed an increase in support for the Lebanese army. It seems as though these days, the Lebanese army is the only group of which majority of our very divided community can agree on. With things getting heated in Tripoli between Salafis and Alawis, it is the duty of the Lebanese army to maintain safety especially with the crisis in our sister country Syria influencing the stability of Lebanon.

While many can argue that the army is incompetent and unequipped to fight a war, and this has been made evident on numerous occasions,  the support for Lebanon’s soldiers is tenacious as they have been able to provide at least internal security between rival factions and sects. With the help of European and Russian training and weaponry donated by several countries, the Lebanese army is able to keep things settled down.

However, in Lebanon I’ve come to find that adoration has made it easier for exoneration. Many Lebanese will deny the crimes in the past, or present, to simply suite their political views. I found this to be the case recently.

As I said earlier, I can understand the dedication to Lebanon’s army. No one can deny those who have fought and died to keep permanence internally. But it seems to me, in these few weeks, the army has been glorified in a way that has made them seem flawless. And this is most definitely not the case.

Yes I am talking about the Palestinian refugees of Lebanon, a very controversial and tense topic in Lebanon due to previous clashes between Palestinians and Lebanese. With the 2007 Nahr ElBared conflict still fresh on the minds of Lebanese everywhere, tensions have only become worse within the two communities. Since then, the camp has been besieged by the army making life there that much more difficult that it already was.

Image of Nahr ElBared after 2007 conflict. Read “Nahr ElBared residents describe life under Lebanese army siege”

From my observations of visiting the Bourj ElShamali Refugee camp in South Lebanon, I witnessed the Lebanese army humiliating young Palestinian refugee scouts simply trying to leave the camp to visit a presentation on psychological and physical illnesses. As perhaps the only one of Lebanese descent t in the bus, I was incredibly ashamed at this action. I knew from previous accounts that this was not the first or last time this had happened and this was not the only camp that had been made victim to this type of humiliation. I could not fathom what the purpose of that was and if it was absolutely necessary that the army had to stop us to search a bus full of kids.

Lest we forget the crimes of the army on June 15th, when Lebanese soldiers shot and killed an innocent 16 year old bystander, Ahmed Qassem, in Nahr ElBared after an argument with others. News of the murder was conflicting and untypically, much unconfirmed news hit the world wide web- some even claiming that the victim was a part of an armed faction.

As someone who is avid in the cause of Palestinians in Lebanon, I was disgusted by these claims. The Lebanese army have been oppressing Palestinian refugees in Lebanon for decades, humiliating them and depriving them of easy access to to obtain basic necessities. While many will argue that it is to maintain stability, and while that may be justified with many cases, the downright lack of respect for refugees by the army is absolutely unacceptable and unforgivable. The army shows little patience for Palestinians  and usually results in poor restraint when it comes using violence against them. To me, the army is using similar tactics of the Israeli army by disallowing even the simplest action of patience and understanding. Maybe if we had a little bit of that, young Ahmed Qassem’s life would have been spared.

Read “Ramblings of a tired Arab girl” about my feelings regarding Palestinian refugees in Lebanon.

Categories: Israel, Lebanon, Palestine | 2 Comments

Why You Shouldn’t Donate To UNESCO

On October 31, 2011, the bid proposed by the President of the Palestinian Authority Mahmoud Abbas to have Palestine gain full membership in UNESCO was passed with a whopping 107 countries voting yes, 52 abstaining and 13 opposing. The bill played well for symbolism and acknowledgment of a very controversial land and perhaps even made Palestine look like it had decent sovereignty under the PA. Though within hours after the bill was passed the US, who had promised to veto it, held a press conference announcing that it would cut 60 million dollars of aid to UNESCO quite possibly putting the organization at risk. Washington only recently rejoined the UNESCO team under the George W. Bush administration after having pulled out in the 80’s and has been providing the organization with 22 percent of its aid.

 

UNESCO is the branch of the United Nations (UN) that calls for peace by educating through science, culture and history. By passing the bill, UNESCO not only recognized Palestine as a state but as a cultural and historical land proving that it has always existed, making Israel’s plan of making their country fully Jewish illegitimate.

 

After the aid cut- a call came from online activists for Palestine to start a project to raise the money cut by the US and donate it to UNESCO. Not only is that a large sum of money and perhaps probably not a main concern for some, but the aim is to make a statement to the US- we are not going to let you bully us with money.

 

Within a few hours, the project had broadened in most social media websites and hundreds climbed onboard, mostly from Europe. “YOU SHARE US’ SHAME OR DONATE TO UNESCO?” painted some blogs’ headlines and Twitter accounts and Facebook pages began springing up everywhere. Even a website called www.donateunesco.org was created, asking more people to join the campaign with hopes of returning the 60 million dollar paycheck the US snatched away.

 

But by making this statement, how are we really benefitting from it? Do we even benefit from it at all? Is UNESCO really on our side? With a little research, it’s not hard to uncover that the organization may have “Goldstoned” us and tricked us into thinking that it really cares about Palestinian rights. While as a whole, it might not be completely fickle, it has done its fair share of sweeping Israeli crimes under the rug which Palestinians cannot afford right now. At such a crucial time where Palestine is searching for recognition, UNESCO, at one point, was actually aiding in the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people’s land in a subtle way.

 

UNESCO, which claims to preserve cultural and historical sights, did a bad job of helping to protect the Temple Mount, a sacred land located in Jerusalem for most monotheistic religions. The land was captured in 1967 during the six day war and has been under Israeli authority ever since. Israel has been illegally destroying Islamic artifacts in Temple Mount to conceal evidence that Muslims inhabited the land at any point. In 2007, a UNESCO session was held to hold Israel accountable for its crimes, but then was dropped and the Israeli government was never charged. This not only fuels Israel to continue to perpetuate said crimes again but also goes against what UNESCO stands for. It makes one wonder what the point of its existence is in the region if it’s just going to drop cases that are not only important to Palestinian culture, but to spiritual ones as well.

 

There is also the issue that the bid for statehood is not black and white. You cannot just recognize a state without actually acknowledging the state it is in now. While the outer appearance of UNESCO’s move with the statehood bid may look like a good idea, beneath it really is just another silly game of politics. The bid made by the PA calls for a two-state solution on 1967 borders that includes West Bank, East Jerusalem as the capitol and the Gaza strip, currently besieged by Israel, which means that is only 22% of Palestinian land giving Israel the rest of Jerusalem and the rest of the land it had already occupied in the past 63 years. However, a day after the bid was put in place, Israel called for the accelerated construction of 2000 illegal settlements in the West Bank and Jerusalem- on the very little land promised to the Palestinians for a future state. How can a state be built on a land that is still being seized by Israel? Surely it would be logical for a powerful organization like the UN to call for imposing sanctions on illegal settlement building first rather than call for a Palestinian state which, although is based on a map from 1967, doesn’t really have borders that aren’t under Israeli authority. Not to mention, scattered Israeli checkpoints infiltrating Palestinian land where Palestinians are often subjected to beatings and unfair detainment or stopped for hours making traveling from one city to another excruciating. Although these lands are promised to be included in a Palestinian state, they are also still under Israeli occupation. It seems as though the only thing promised by UNESCO is a Bantustan state, similar to the apartheid of South Africa, disallowing Palestine to ever be independent in the future.

 

But by stopping settlements, this goes completely against what Israel wants- which is more Palestinian land. The notion of a two-state is only emphasized on one side; the side of Israel. So why would we donate to an organization that will ultimately only provide for Israel in the end and not be as punctual about the problems of Palestinians? Another one of the issues being Palestinian refugee rights.

 

What will happen to the Palestinian refugees who rightfully dwell on their “Right to Return”. If a state is only settled on 1/3 of their land, where exactly will they return? Palestinians who dispersed in neighboring Arab countries being forced to spend the rest of their lives as refugees live in some of the most horrid conditions, especially those in Lebanon where the living has been compared to the besieged Gaza strip. It seems that by settling for this two-sate compromise, most will not even be able to go live in their land making their situation no different than it is now.

 

Although the recognition of Palestine may be enough for some, it is not enough to pledge such a large about of money that one can’t even promise will go to Palestine. In the end, words are words and it is actions that matter. UNESCO taking the reigns of the statehood bid only leaves us to an organization that continues to contradict itself, so long as it continues to surrender to Israel who has shown us that they are the ultimate decision makers. Why should the people finance something that goes against their morals?

 

Categories: Israel, Palestine | Tags: , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Why Citizen Journalism Rocks and Real Journalism is Dead To Me

August 19:

Eliat attacks occur. At least 7 Israelis dead. No one knows who did it. Everyone is in shock. The news ate this news story up; from CNN, to NBC all the way to Al Jazeera.

A few hours later, Israeli politician Ehud Barak accused Gaza “militants” to be behind the attack without providing any information or facts to back up his claim and promised that Gaza would “pay”. But suddenly then, everyone forgot about this important story that was only developing into something worse.

Perfect timing for Israel. Or was the silence deliberate?

It was only a matter of time before Israel started bombarding the strip on all corners: North, East, West, South. By the end of the day, 7 were killed, including 2-year-old Islam Qreiqe on his birthday, and many critically injured. All this information, I found via Twitter; a source I have been turning to for quite some time especially since the Arab revolutions began. Citizen journalism was definitely one of the ways to go for me, but I still needed that hardcore journalism. You know- reporters in helmets and bullet proof PRESS vests, working tirelessly to provide information that I so desperately needed to know.

So I frantically turn on my favorite news channel, Al Jazeera English, which had impeccable coverage of the Gaza massacre in 2008-09. I thought- well, if something is happening in Palestine, AJE has got my back right?

Turn on the TV. A documentary is playing. “Oh okay” I said, “I’ll read the scrolling headlines”. Nothing. Zip. Nada. But oh wait, they’re talking about the Egyptian soldiers that were killed in a brawl between Israeli soldiers. Phew, so they are paying attention. But why no Gaza? Where is Gaza?

So I did something that was unlike me- I started flipping to other news channels. BBC, CNN, SKY and NOTHING. Perhaps by now there would have been a mention of it in the scroll bar, but it was probably so small of a mention that I forgot or the words went by too fast…

Were Gazans making this up? No way. I mean why would they? Not one news station was playing any sort of reportage from the strip, I started becoming skeptical. But I shook it off my skepticism because I know Israel and I thought it was a one day thing where they went completely ballistic and took out all it’s aggression on Gaza like it typically does. I thought it was over. I let the media silence slide. Then the “BREAKING” tweets start reappearing on my timeline from average Palestinians living in the strip and it went on for 2 days into the attacks on Gaza. More deaths, more injuries, still no evidence by Barak that Palestinian militants were behind the Eliat conflict.

Again, I quickly open my TV and see the headlines, “Libya, Syria, more Libya”. Very important news. Gaza is just as important right? Oh look, Gaza reportage…I can’t wait to see what they’re about to repo..

“Hamas has broken the 2 year truce. Gaza rockets are now being fired into Israel, we are now going to speak to an Israeli spokesperson…”
WHAT!?!

Gaza has been getting bombarded for nearly 3 days in a row, the death toll had been risen to 15 by then and 40 people were critically injured and NOW all of a sudden they feel like reporting about it? When Hamas breaks the so called “truce”? Maybe the news forgot that the night before the Eliat attacks, Israel bombed Rafah? Oh but that’s not breaking the truce until a homemade rocket is fired, right?

So I drag myself back onto my computer and see minute to minute updates on the situation in Gaza. Every explosion reported, every injury acknowledged, every person murdered was given a name. I’m shocked. Not only by what’s happening, but the fact that these unpaid average civilians were doing a better job than any top notch news agency who apparently think some news stories are more important than others.

Five days into the bombardment, I had stopped watching the news. My journalism dreams= dead. My love for the news was gone. I found a new source of information: Citizen journalism. I too took part in this, yet did not more than confirm reports with other Gaza tweeps and retweet on Twitter. It was so easy to get news now, but I underestimated how hard it would be to get it heard. While I have to give credit to average people around the world WANTING to learn more about the situation and wanting to help out: the lack of actual TV coverage was disheartening. It basically meant that if people didn’t search for Gaza, then everyone who didn’t wouldn’t know what was going on. I know that if I hadn’t signed onto Twitter, I wouldn’t have known.

So is Gaza’s story exclusively for twitter now and for people who feel like reporting on it? Because personally, I’d think that 5 days of heavy bombardment (which is slowly halting, but still occurring as I type this) seems like important news to me.

Categories: Gaza, Israel, Media | Tags: , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Wear Red for Palestine- Success!

I’m happy to announce that the event “Wear Red for Palestine” was a huge success with people wearing red in 21 countries! The event gained over 19,500 members and the number is still growing. The event took place yesterday to commemorate the 2nd year anniversary of Israel’s brutal attack of the Gaza strip which lasted 22 days and killed 1,400 people, mostly women and children.

Places that participated in the Wear Red for Palestine event:

Palestine, Qatar, Poland, Lebanon, UK, California, Texas, UAE, Colorado, Arizona, Missouri, Florida, Turkey, Algeria, Greece, Jordan, Italy, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, New Mexico, Bosnia, New York, Canada, Wisconsin, Germany, Austria, Illinois, Ireland, Colombia, France, Connecticut and Malaysia.

Facebook and Twitter turned red too with members updating their profile pictures to that color with a message of solidarity with the Palestinian people. 0.09% of Twitter last night was made of users tweeting the hashtag “#Gaza2” from all over the world!

#Gaza2 hashtag being used all over the world. (Photo via @AmoonaE on Twitter)
(Photo via @AmoonaE on Twitter)

Despite rude comments about how this event would change nothing, it never brought Palestinian activists down and most certainly didn’t bring me down. Thousands of people united, in the name of Palestine, to spread justice and educate the world about the oppression they have been too blind to see. We will continue to take advantage of our freedom until Palestinians are able to have their own! You will not be silenced, our beloved Falasteen.

Categories: Gaza, Israel | 1 Comment

ENGLISH Walkthrough: Sayyed Nasrallah’s speech on 11/28/2010

Leader of Hezbollah, Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, has addressed the Lebanese public tonight speaking about the ongoing situation of Israel tapping Lebanon’s telecommunications. It has been known that Israel taps into one of Lebanon’s leading cellphone lines “Alfa” and now, Mr. Nasrallah went into details of how they actually do it and what danger it could put the Lebanese people in. He stated:

“The telecommunications sector hasn’t only been penetrated but completely controlled by the Israelis. […] No telephone in Lebanon is safe from Israel’s penetration; the Israelis can crack any code and any phone in Lebanon. Israel can make phone calls from your number, using your name, without your knowledge. Israel can also send text messages from any phone; they can manipulate the time and place of the owner of the phone. Israel can make a phone call from Beirut while you’re in Sidon; or from Baalbeck while you are in Bint Jbeil.”

Mr. Nasrallah also mentioned that there were “two lines in the Lebanese telecommunications sector” and that “one line belongs to the Lebanese and a phone line that belongs to Israel”. He thanked the Lebanese army for uncovering this information.

“We must salute our brothers, the technical experts in the Resistance and the Lebanese army for discovering this info. Of course people will call to the Lebanese Army Intelligence and accuse them of being spies. But after our discovery it has been proven that our brothers in the army are not spies. They are the victims of the Israeli infiltration and we must be vigilant in continuing to expose this.”

Changing the subject swiftly, Mr. Nasrallah started discussing the very controversial tribunal for assassinated Prime Minsiter Rafik Hariri in which Hezbollah members will possibly be indicted. He stated that prosecutor Daniel Bellemare’s indictment was not credible if he based it on telecommunications.

“It seems this tribunal makes its own rules and does it whatever it wants. How can this tribunal be given such an authority? I have some questions to ask the Tribunal after consultation with several legal experts. […] The accused must be brought forth before an indictment can be issued. This tribunal is silent regarding the witness; it doesn’t allow the questioning of the witness. […] Why was prosecutor Bellemare in such a bad state when he made his comments on CBC? This is the same information broadcasted from Der Spiegel. This is not evidence; these are media reports. This is not credible evidence which an indictment can be built upon. I call on everyone to stop wasting time. “

He accused the tribunal of only being for political indictment and the UNSC of being “unconstitutional”:

“This Tribunal is a not legal or constitutional issue in Lebanon, it is a UNSC issue. The same UNSC which divided Palestine and recognized the illegitimate entity of Israel. The same UNSC that is a tool in the hands of the United States of America.”

Mr. Nasrallah held onto his claims of Israeli involvement in the assassination of Mr. Hariri and it how they are trying to disarm Hezbollah through this tribunal.

“Israeli officials have admitted that they have given information to this Tribunal. Israeli officials have collaborated in the investigation of the Tribunal. The Israelis themselves are talking about this. The Israelis have collaborated with the Tribunal to rid themselves of their enemy: the Lebanese Resistance. To the Zionist entity, we are a challenge; we are a competitor that has prevented all of their projects in Lebanon. […] Waiting until after the indictment will benefit nobody but Israel and lead to more aggression. “

Mr. Nasrallah spoke briefly about the recent “pull-out” of Israeli occupation forces on the Lebanese-Syrian village of Ghajar. He told the Lebanese public that it was merely an attempt by Israel to “cover up it’s eating away of territories in occupied Palestine” and to “improve Israel’s image”:

“It is very clear that the Israelis are playing around with this while continuing its settlement activity (in Palestine). […] Ghajar is an occupied territory; Israel has no right to tell anyone who should take control of the territory. Until Ghajar is returned to the Lebanese army, to Lebanese sovereignty, it is still occupied. Israel must withdraw from all of Ghajar; not just the Lebanese part of Ghajar and the Syrian part of Ghajar.”

Before concluding his speech, Mr. Nasrallah reassured supporters of the strength of Hezbollah.

We are not afraid. Never before in the history of our country has our Resistance been so strong and so confident.

Special thanks, as always, to Sarah Abdallah for English translations (@Jnoubiyeh on Twitter). You can find her website here: http://jnoubiyeh.com/

Categories: Israel, Lebanon | 1 Comment

Walkthrough: Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah speech on 10/28/10

Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, leader of Hezbollah, made a very short speech tonight in Lebanon revealing startling information, that has endangered the privacy of Lebanese civilians.

He begun his speech by quickly getting to the point. He told the Lebanese public that the Special committee for the STL (Special Tribunal of Lebanon, for assassinated Prime Minister Rafik Hariri), was requesting private information of Lebanese civilians. He stated:

“The Special Investigation Committee made many requests including the files from private universities from 2003-2006. Telephones and SMS messages from 2003 until now were all given to the Special Investigation Committee. The Committee also requested passports from the Lebanese General Security. 893 Lebanese peoples’ fingerprints were requested as well as DNA information and geographical information. They wanted everything regarding Lebanon’s geography from border to border; valleys, mountains, everything.”

Sayyed Nasrallah also gave details on where this information is going, but not why it is needed. He said:

“We also do know that the data & the information given to the Special Committee is then given to Western intelligence and Israel. “

He spoke about why Hezbollah didn’t interfere with these requests and why they were not stopped.

“Despite this fact, we remained silent. Why were we silent? We were silent so we wouldn’t be accused of disrupting the investigation. We were silent because of the martyr Rafiq Hariri’s family. We were silent to let them grieve. But the political reasons and internal reasons and foreign reasons are no longer relevant. We can no longer be silent. The silence stops here. I am asking, why does the International Tribunal need the files and data it is requesting?”

The most startling piece of evidence is that of the Special Committee requesting personal medical files from women’s clinics inside of Lebanon. Sayyed Nasrallah condemned this act, stating:

“Will any single of you, the people of Lebanon, accept that someone look at the files of your wife, your daughter of your sister? Is there any honorable person anywhere that would accept this? Their female family members examined by international investigators? We as Lebanese, have ethical values, righteous values. We do not accept this. The legal experts have told me this is forbidden from a legal perspective as well as a humanitarian perspective.”

He has asked Lebanese officials to boycott the investigation.

“Any cooperation with the investigation is contributing to the assault and the attack on the Lebanese Resistance. Some people have been threatened by the STL so they cooperate. We have this recorded. I call on all Lebanese officials to act according to their morals, their dignity, and their honor when called upon by the Investigation”

Sayyed Nasrallah ended the speech abruptly with,

“The files of your sons and daughters my brothers and sisters is now in the hands of the Israelis. We must not accept this, we must take responsibility, and we must take action.”

Many thanks to Sarah Abdallah (@Jnoubiyeh on Twitter) for the English translation of this speech. You may find her website here http://www.jnoubiyeh.com

Categories: Israel, Lebanon | 1 Comment

Walkthrough: Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah Speech 8/24/10

Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, chief of Hezbollah, has brought to the table numerous topics in his recent speech.

Aiding the Lebanese Army

In the first part of his speech, he spoke about the intentions of the weaponry given to the Lebanese Army by the US. He stated,

“What happened in the last confrontation between Israel and the Lebanese army tells us much about the weapons the US gives us. The weapons the US gives to Lebanon are not given to fight Israel, but are given for internal purposes. We will never accept conditions for US aid, we don’t need US aid.”

He also accused the US of giving arms to the Lebanese army to stop Lebanon into “falling into the hands of Hezbollah”.

Sayyed Nasrallah  spoke about countries, specifically Iran, and how they should aid the Lebanese Army with weapons in order to defend themselves from the Israeli army. He also spoke of the urgency regarding the supplying of weapons.

“We don’t want to buy weapons, we need weapons. We must tell our brothers in Iran to help with whatever they can.

Iran will give equipment to the Lebanese Army without any conditions. I suggest the government come to a decision on this. “

The President of Iran is due to visit Lebanon after Ramadan.

Israeli Spies in Lebanon

A big problem in Hezbollah and Lebanon’s security is the huge amount of Lebanese spies working for Israel. Sayyed Nasrallah stressed that the punishment for the spies must be tougher and the death penalties must continue to be used.

“What makes someone hesitate and not spy for Israel? The death penalty. This will stop Israel recruiting. Punishment invigorates a society. If you do not have punishment for wrongdoing, it destroys a society.”

He talked about the immunity Hezbollah has against internal spies and why it would be difficult for Israel to infiltrate the resistance.

“When I say no, we dont have spies in Hezbollah, I am not saying it because we are Hezbollah. I am saying it because we are immune. I would like to say, on this table of Iftar, that we dont have spies in Hezbollah because Israel has no information on Hezbollah. If you want to join this organization, you will be subjected to interrogation even if you are the son of the secretary…”

The Tribunal Regarding Prime Minister Rafik Hariri

A part of the speech was dedicated to the tribunal regarding the late Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, who was assassinated in 2005 after a car bomb exploded. In a previous speech, Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah shared hard hitting evidence, revealing Israeli drone tapes tracking the late Prime Minister’s movement in all around Lebanon. He also supplied proof of Lebanese spies working for Israel, admitting that they were giving false testimonies.  He accused Israel of murdering Mr. Hariri and demanded that charges against Hezbollah men to be dropped. In tonight’s speech, he talked about the dangers in the way the International Tribunal is being handled:

“Does the International Tribunal control what the Lebanese Judiciary should do? This is dangerous for Lebanon for false witnesses to be used by international bodies against our country. Whatever you want to name them, the truth doesn’t change. We have a group of individuals who have given false testimony. For the sake of justice, the Lebanese must know who created the false witnesses. The voice must continue to be raised until the Lebanese get this right. It is our national right to know the truth.”

“I said i wouldn’t give 100% concrete evidence, I said I would give evidence that would open a new horizon for the investigation. […] I gave my evidence to the Lebanese Judiciary, not to the International Tribunal. I will not be dragged into this political game of the International Tribunal, I will make my comments at the appropriate time.”

In the last part of his speech, topics such as Lebanon’s complicated electricity and water situation were discussed.

Tuesday, August 24th, 2010.

Special thanks to @Jnoubiyeh on Twitter (http://twitter.com/Jnoubiyeh) for the English Translation. You may find her website here: http://www.jnoubiyeh.com/

Categories: Israel, Lebanon | Tags: , , , | 1 Comment

The day the Flotilla became a business deal for Israel

Written by Ann Wright on Common Dreams (commondreams.org) http://www.commondreams.org/view/2010/08/22-5

Israeli Soldiers Sell Gaza Flotilla Passengers’ Computers and Steal Hundreds of Thousands of Dollars in Cash

Israeli Government Refuses to Secure Criminal Evidence

Despite appeals from 750 passengers on the Gaza flotilla to their governments to pressure the Israeli government to protect and return their personal belongings that were taken by Israeli commandos on May 31, 2010, when they forcefully boarded the six ships of the flotilla, the Israeli government has left millions of dollars of computers, cameras and cell phones and hundreds of thousands of cash unsecured and un-inventoried. An Israeli newspaper has revealed that four to six computers among the hundreds that were taken from passengers on the six ships have been sold by an Israeli First Lieutenant to three junior military personnel. On August 18, a second officer was arrested in connection with the theft. An Israeli military official described the case as “embarrassing and shameful.” Eitan Kabel, a member of parliament from the Labour party, told Israeli media: “This is an embarrassing, humiliating and infuriating act.”

Israeli government informed of passengers’ property by Embassies

Passengers from the six ships gave detailed lists of their property to consular officers from their respective Embassies while the passengers were in the Beer-Shiva prison on June 2. All passengers who were flown from Israel on June 4 to Turkey also gave another list of their possessions to consular officials in Istanbul, Turkey. Most passengers followed up with letters to their respective Ministries of Foreign Affairs or Department of State and to lawyers who will be filing lawsuits for deaths and injuries inflicted by the Israeli military and claims for stolen property.

Evidence of commandos’ actions on cameras, cell phones and computers should be available for independent investigation and possible criminal cases

Evidence on the flotilla passengers’ cameras, cell phones and computers should be a part of the evaluation by an independent panel to determine when and where 9 passengers on the Mavi Marmara were killed and when and where 50 other passengers were wounded. With the exception of two camera cards that survived endless body inspections on the ships, in the initial processing center at Ashdod port and in the prison, all the photos and video footage taken by 750 passengers is in the possession of the Israeli government.

Hundreds of Thousands of Dollars of Cash Taken by Commandos

Israeli commandos also took cash and credit cards from passengers. A conservative estimate of $1000 cash per passenger gives a total of $750,000 cash that was taken from passengers. Commandos with weapons demanded cash from passengers stating they were “to take the money for safekeeping.” Many passengers had been fundraising in their home areas to have funds to deliver to non-governmental organizations. Other passengers were taking money to families in Gaza from family members living outside of Gaza. I personally know of four persons on the passenger ships who had a total $68,000 in cash taken by commandos.

Israeli military can find out who took the equipment and money–if they want to

The Israeli military is certainly capable of finding out who took the money and equipment if they wish. The Israeli military knows exactly which military unit boarded each of the six ships, the names of each of the commandos that were on each ship and the leaders of each unit. Passengers do not know the names of the commandos as their uniforms were stripped of nametags, rank and unit insignia and they kept black masks on throughout the hours they were on the ships. The Israeli military can order the leaders of each unit to testify if they know if any member of their unit took money or equipment and whether they have noticed if any unit member has suddenly had a change in his lifestyle that might be attributed to having stolen money or sold equipment from the passengers. As a retired U.S. Army Colonel with 29 years in the military, I know that the barracks gossip in the military unit involved will provide some information about the stolen property and money. Checking the pawnshops near the military bases is a good bet as they are likely places that stolen goods will appear. New cars, cell phones, electronic equipment that is above the “pay-grade” of a military members is a dead give-away that the person has somehow come into new money and is living beyond his means.

U.S. military court-martials in 1984 for theft by U.S. military during Grenada invasion

I speak from experience about military personnel taking the possessions of others. In 1984, 13 soldiers from the 82nd Airborne Division of Fort Bragg, North Carolina were court-martialed and found guilty of stealing property of civilians in Grenada when the U.S. military invaded and occupied that country. I was on the U.S. military claims commission and received the complaints from Grenadians that after U.S. military personnel had occupied their houses, jewelry, money and various items were missing. We immediately asked the criminal investigative office at Fort Bragg to go to the pawn shops around Fort Bragg to look for the items, and they found most of the them at the shops. The soldiers considered that the property of the Grenadians were “spoils of war.” One young private even wrote an article for the Fayetteville, North Carolina newspaper in which he proudly described in detail what he had taken as “spoils of war.” He was court-martialed and sentenced to several months in prison. In the same manner, I suspect that the commandos decided that since their government was labeling everyone on the flotilla as “terrorists,” that no one in the government would care if they took “spoils of war,” the possessions of the “terrorists.”

Leadership and Accountablility in the Israeli military?

I have no doubts that members of the commando units know exactly who took what and where the money and equipment is. It takes good military leadership to understand the breakdown in unit integrity and want to correct it. We will see by the actions of the Israeli military and government what type of leadership and accountability they have.

Ann Wright is a retired US Army Reserve Colonel with 29 years of service and 16 years as a US diplomat who resigned in March, 2003 in opposition to the Iraq war. She was in Gaza three times in 2009, helped organize the 1350 person Gaza Freedom March in December, 2009 and was on the Gaza flotilla.

Categories: Gaza, Israel, Palestine | Tags: , , , , | Leave a comment

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.